Thanks for this lesson idea. I just thought I'd share the direction I went with it.
I ended up turning it into a dialogue class. I did a quick intro on how to ask for suggestions and offer suggestions. Then, in groups of four each person had to come up with something they wanted to ask their group for help with and each person in the group had to offer a suggestion for each question. Then I had them share it as a dialogue with the class, or what is more often the case in my classes, I ran around and listened to each of them read their dialogues to me. They seemed to have fun with it. I got a lot of things like this:
I'm fall in love with her. Can you give me some advice?
You should find another girl. Look your face!
If I were you, I would show her my mind.
You should propose her.
...which also made it fun for me
